All good things must come to an end. Those were my exact thoughts as I exited A Mano (24 Franklin Avenue) in Ridgewood, New Jersey. This massive pizza place was the final stop on a recent New Jersey pizza tour. The last stop is always a dangerous one. You have to make sure you’re not too full to enjoy the pizza. And you must not be fatigued from all of the pizza eating up to that point. Our travels earlier in the day had taken us to Santillo’s in Elizabeth (639 South Broad Street), Star Tavern in Orange (400 Hight Street), and Ah’ Pizz in Montclair (7 N. Willow Street).
It’s impossible to write about A Mano without first focusing on the space. This bi-level restaurant is massive. Many of New York City’s most popular pizza places seat about 50 people (Does Size Matter?). A large place might hold 100-150. But A Mano is in a different league. Our waitress estimated that the restaurant could hold up to 300 people. To accommodate diners on busy nights there is not one… but two ovens. They are the centerpiece of the restaurant and can be viewed from the majority of tables. There is also a bar on the lower level which serves drinks and handmade gelato.
One of my concerns about A Mano is that there are 28 pies on the menu. This is by far the most pies I have ever seen on a menu at a Neapolitan pizza place (or any pizza place, for that matter). Although I understand they want to give their large clientele many options, it is impossible to make 28 spectacular pies. A Mano could benefit from shortening it’s menu a bit. I’m in favor of interesting and innovative topping combinations, but I don’t think A Mano would suffer from eliminating their 10-12 least popular pies.
We ended our day with a Margherita pie (fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, parmiggiano reggiano, extra virgin olive oil, basil) and… to spice things up… a Pear & Gorganzola pie (gorganzola dolce, sliced pear, walnuts, parmiggiano reggiano, extra virgin olive oil, basil).
The Margherita ($10.99) was solid, although they went extremely light on the basil as you can see below. At that point, what’s the point of even putting basil on the pie? Everything else about the pie was spot on. The crust was the best we’d had all day — airy and fluffy, yet strong enough to hold the pie together.
The price of some of A Mano’s pies neared $20.00 and considering the Margherita pie was more expensive than at Paulie Gee’s or Roberta’s, I’d say that A Mano is a bit of a burden on the wallet. Nevertheless, the space is magnificent and the pies are delicious. I’m not that familiar with Ridgewood, New Jersey… but if I had to guess… I’d say this is your best bet for scoring some good pizza in the area. Worth the trip out from New York City? Probably not. But it’s good to know that Jersey can at least give the Big Apple a run for it’s money. Literally.