WHAT'S NEW?
 
Home / Reviews / New York / Totonno’s: High Expectation Are Hard To Meet
Totonno’s: High Expectation Are Hard To Meet

Totonno’s: High Expectation Are Hard To Meet

Back in March 2009, a devastating fire forced Totonno’s – a legendary Coney Island pizza place – to close indefinitely (Fire Shuts Totonno’s). Weeks passed and false reports of a reopening date surfaced from time to time. Finally, nearly a year after the fire, Totonno’s was back in business. The only problem? It was the …

Review Overview

Overall Experience - 6.4

6.4

Summary : A trip to this legendary Coney Island pizza place was disappointing.

6

Back in March 2009, a devastating fire forced Totonno’s – a legendary Coney Island pizza place – to close indefinitely (Fire Shuts Totonno’s). Weeks passed and false reports of a reopening date surfaced from time to time. Finally, nearly a year after the fire, Totonno’s was back in business. The only problem? It was the middle of winter in New York City — not exactly a prime time to be visiting Coney Island. Nevertheless, loyal customers returned right away and when the cold weather was gone, the place was packed once again — as if it had never even closed.

Sadly, I never made it to the original Totonno’s. From what I hear, not much has changed. Ever since I started Pizza Club in 2008, I’d been looking forward to organizing an outing there. And last month, it was finally time to make the trip. I was worried, though, that I wouldn’t be able to form an objective opinion about the pizza there. For years now, I’ve been hearing about how amazing the pizza is at Totonno’s. Nearly every pizza enthusiast I meet lists it as one of their favorite places. Even before I set foot inside, I already had unrealistically high expectations for what I’d find behind those glass doors.

The place itself feels like it’s been around for decades. The walls are adorned with photos and plaques of awards and reviews. About 35-40 people can comfortably fit inside — most at tables, some in booths. The way Totonno’s is arranged makes it difficult to accommodate large parties. Had our group been larger than seven people, I fear we would have encountered a problem. When the place is full, as it was on a Friday evening around 7PM, a disorderly line forms outside. When a table opens up, the place’s no-nonsense owner, Louise Ciminieri, steps outside to let in the next party.

The pizza itself was underwhelming. It was good. Solid. Enjoyable. Tasty. But it wasn’t all I hoped and dreamed it would be. We ordered three pies – one plain, one with sausage, and one with mushrooms and peppers. Our group seemed to agree the the toppings only took away from the key ingredients. The plain pie was the best.

At $19.50 for a large pie, it seems in line with other classic Brooklyn pizza places. A large pie at Grimaldi’s is $14.00, but at Di Fara you’ll have to shell out $25.00. Totonno’s, however, is a far cry from Di Fara. I was disappointed there was no basil on the plain pie and the crust was crunchier than I like. Some of the pies were lukewarm when they arrived. I love when a pie is placed in front of you… still steaming from the oven.

I’m sure I’ll return to Totonno’s very soon and perhaps my opinion about it will change. When a pizza place involves a bit of a trek to get to, I ask myself this: Would I send a friend from out of town there for some pizza? The answer is a resounding no. Other Brooklyn pizza places I might send them to include Di Fara, Grimaldi’s, Paulie Gee’s, Motorino and Roberta’s. I’m perhaps ashamed to say that I even enjoyed a place like Toby’s Public House more than Totonno’s. I appreciate the history and it’s somewhere every New Yorker should visit. I just don’t appreciate the pizza as much as I do elsewhere. Had I gone with lower expectations, perhaps I would have been pleasantly surprised. But when you’re expecting greatness, it’s easy to be disappointed.

About I Dream Of Pizza

Some guys dream about winning the Powerball jackpot, making love to Kate Upton, or scoring the winning touchdown in the Super Bowl. But personally, I spend most of my time dreaming about digging my face into a mouth watering slice of pizza. Fireworks are ignited. Music comes out of nowhere. And just like that, I’ve fallen in love once again. Since 2008, I've chronicled my pizza eating adventures in New York City and around the world on I Dream Of Pizza -- the web's most popular blog dedicated entirely to pizza.

15 comments

  1. Thanks so much for the post.Really thank you! Great.https://genericedpills20.com/

  2. Please wait outside of the house.

  3. Undeniably believe that which you said. Your favorite justification appeared to be on the net the simplest factor to be mindful of.
    I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people think about concerns that they just don’t realize about.
    You controlled to hit the nail upon the top and also outlined out the whole thing without having side-effects , folks could
    take a signal. Will likely be again to get more. Thank you

  4. Definitely imagine that which you said. Your
    favourite justification seemed to be at the web the simplest factor to
    remember of. I say to you, I definitely get irked while people consider concerns that they just do not recognise about.
    You controlled to hit the nail upon the top and outlined out the whole thing with no need side-effects , other people can take a signal.
    Will probably be again to get more. Thanks

  5. This information is priceless. When can I find out more?

  6. I’m not that much of a online reader to be honest but your
    blogs really nice, keep it up! I’ll go ahead and bookmark your site to come back later on.
    Many thanks

  7. Sweet blog! I found it while searching on Yahoo News. Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
    I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there!
    Many thanks

  8. I’ve been exploring for a bit for any high-quality articles or
    weblog posts in this sort of space . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this site.
    Reading this info So i am satisfied to show that I have a very excellent uncanny feeling I found
    out just what I needed. I most surely will make sure to don?t
    overlook this web site and give it a glance on a continuing basis.

  9. I simply want to mention I am just very new to blogging and actually enjoyed your website. Most likely I’m likely to bookmark your website . You definitely have fantastic articles. Many thanks for sharing your web site.

  10. replica watches are amazing reproduction of original authentic swiss luxury time pieces.

  11. Would you be intrigued in trading links?

  12. My partner and I stumbled over here coming from a different page and thought I might check things out. I like what I see so now i am following you. Look forward to exploring your web page repeatedly.

  13. Nice post. I learn some thing more difficult on various blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating you just read content using their company writers and use a little something from their site. I’d would prefer to use some with all the content in my small weblog no matter whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll provide you with a link on the internet weblog. Many thanks sharing.

  14. Can I just state what an alleviation to discover somebody that in fact knows what theyre speaking about on the net. You certainly recognize exactly how to bring a problem to light as well as make it important. Even more individuals need to read this and also comprehend this side of the tale. I cant think youre not much more prominent due to the fact that you certainly have the gift.

  15. I was very delighted to find this web-site. I intended to thanks for your time for this remarkable read!! I most definitely taking pleasure in every little bit of it as well as I have you bookmarked to look into new things you article.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll To Top